The other day I was working with a Manager who has continuously demonstrated to the workforce that he wants them to have control of their own destiny. He has supported this workforce with training, leadership development skills, and defined metrics or criteria for success.
Yet his workforce still does not fully trust him.
Here is a recent scenario. He has decided to change the schedule of the call center employees.
After collecting several months of data, he came to realize that most calls were coming in on Mondays and Tuesdays during day time hours. Currently the workforce has a 24 x7 rotating shift schedule. One of the perks is a 7 day break for the workforce.
So, he showed each of the employees the data. He told him he wanted 7 day coverage for 12 hour days. It was obvious from the data that this was the best solution. Then he told them that he wanted them to design the schedule. His criteria:
a) Cost neutral to both the employee and the company
b) Easy to manage (knows who is supposed to be on and who is supposed to be off)
c) 7 days covered and 12 hours covered
It was unbelievable the response that he received.
They hated the idea. Some of the employees felt that he was trying to take away their seven day break. Others had side jobs and felt that the new schedule would not allow this continue. They cried, they wined, they felt he was putting the screws to them.
Well, this went on for four days. The manager could not go into the call center area without a hush falling over the place. He knew something was up. And he was upset about it. He received some feedback from some of his lieutenants about the employees’ issues.
So here is what he did.
He took 15 minutes and created three shift schedules.
Schedule 1: It was exactly like the employees thought it would be. Two days on two days off, three days on three days off. Working two weekends a month. It was cost neutral to the company and the employee. It was simple to manage because there were only two groups or shifts of employees that went through the schedule. No seven day breaks.
Schedule 2: Difficult to explain but it split the two groups into four groups (which was previously assumed to be a constraint.) This new schedule gave the employees six days off in a row and another 5 days off in a row. However, it required them to work 7 days in a row… which is tough. Again cost neutral… but a little more difficult to manage because there were four groups to manage instead of two. Required the teams to work two weekends a month
Schedule 3: Again difficult to explain but in this schedule, more people worked on Monday and Tuesdays. Only one person worked on Saturday and Sunday. And since there were four groups, that meant a person only had to work one weekend a month. Also, they got seven days off in a row. The longest number of working days in a row was four which was exactly what they had in their current schedule. Finally, it was cost neutral to the employee and to the company. Plus it was all day work… no more switching shifts from nights to days to nights.
He walked into the call center and gathered several of the employees around to review the schedule. He took them through each one. Everyone groaned after seeing the first schedule. His comment… yes I thought it sucked too… but it would be easy to manage.
He took them through the next two schedules and he could hardly get done with the third before people were saying that schedule was great. They thought it was awesome. People outside of the department wanted to move to that schedule!
He explained to them that it met all of the criteria laid out. And commented that it took him about 15 minutes to lay out the three schedules.
Guess what he did next.
He took the piece of paper he had everything written on…
And crumbled it up and stuck in his pocket.
Everyone gasped and said how can we explain what you came up with to the other people on the next shift?
‘Easy’ was his reply.
Figure out your own schedule like I asked in the first place.
He walked away knowing that he could walk back into the call center at anytime and the low hum of chatter and laughter would be back.